A cultural fixation on female thinness is not an obsession about female beauty but an obsession about female obedience. – Naomi Wolf (The Beauty Myth)
First, if you haven’t read The Beauty Myth, please do! It will hopefully change your perspective to think about the beauty industry, the women’s movement, female sexuality (and MANY other things) in a new, and empowered way.
Just think about this quote for a minute, and ask yourself, who are females obeying when they try to obtain the impossible thin-ideal?
And what does it actually mean to obey?
o-bey
1. To carry out or fulfill the command, order, or instruction of.
By default, obeying involves subservience, compliance, and unquestioning. When you obey something or someone, you inevitably give up a little bit of your own free will or power.
Of course, this is not to say it’s a bad thing to obey. There are laws in place to keep us safe (ie: traffic regulations) and it’s smart to obey these rules for the benefit of ourselves and those around us. But, what about the rules that don’t have our best intentions in mind (ie: the dieting industry)?
Consider this:
Dieting is the most potent political sedative in women’s history…concern with weight leads to “a virtual collapse of self-esteem and sense of effectiveness… [dieting] results in a distinctive personality whose traits are passivity, anxiety and emotionality…women’s advances had begun to give them the opposite traits – high self-esteem, a sense of effectiveness, activity, courage, and clarity of mind – prolonged and periodic calorie restriction is a means to take the teeth out of this revolution. – Naomi Wolf (The Beauty Myth)
The women’s liberation movement struck a chord of fear in the hearts of those in power – those who wanted to keep women subservient to men – quiet, unquestioning, (read: unequal). But when women took to the streets, joined the workforce, and started demanding equality, a new method of silencing took stage (the dieting/beauty industry). As women were presented with more images of the ideal career woman (enter “Twiggy”), the message that their bodies must be contained and regulated was quickly established. And, as Wolf, so eloquently writes, this shift in focus from making strides in the social and political spheres to body control and weight obsession, shut women up. By physically draining them of energy and concentration ability, dieting kept women distracted from the goal of equal treatment and opportunity. And those in power, stayed in power.
If women cannot eat the same food as men, we cannot experience equal status in the community. As long as women are asked to bring a self-denying mentality to the communal table, it will never be round, men and women seated together; but the same traditional hierarchical dais, with a folding table for women at the foot. – Naomi Wolf (The Beauty Myth)
Are you satisfied with this standard? Are you happy that the more and more women advance, the more their bodies are scrutinized? Just think back to how many times you hear about Michele Obama’s appearance vs. her courage, her intellect, her charisma. By focusing on her appearance vs. her valuable ideas, society is essentially saying that the only thing that matters is her body. And, the message is loud and clear to young girls who, as we know, are dieting and expressing body dissatisfaction at horrendously young ages.
It’s time, as women, to reject this dangerous strategy to keep us quiet, anxious, competitive against one another, dissatisfied, and distracted. It’s time to finally say we’re fed up with the message that we’re only as good as our appearance and begin to comfortably grow into our natural bodies (whatever size and shape we’re genetically disposed to be). It’s time to EAT and not feel guilty or ashamed. It’s time to speak our minds and not try to please everyone or avert confrontation. It’s time to teach our daughters that their worth is NOT based on their size, calories consumed, hours spent on the treadmill, or ability to attract men.
Here’s Wolf’s suggestion:
While we cannot directly affect the images, we can drain them of their power. We can turn away from them, look directly at one another, and find alternative images of beauty in a female subculture: seek out plays, music, films that illuminate women in three dimensions; find the biographies of women, the women’s history, the heroines that in each generation are submerged from view; fill in the terrible, “beautiful” blanks. We can lift ourselves and others out of the [beauty] myth – but only if we are really willing to seek out and support and really look at the alternatives.
Are you ready?
What do you need to overcome the myth that you’re only as “good” as your body compares to images of starvation?
What motivates you?
What women inspire you?
Join me in this revolution.
Riot-Don’t-Diet!

Reading this was like finding a chocolate-covered strawberry in my pint of berries. I’ve perused many blogs tonight, and so far this resonates with my soul on a much deeper level. I’m writing a book and blog called Reclaiming the Plunder of the Body Image Bandit to encourage women to become the people they were meant to be. It’s a combination of psychology, humor, narrative, and research. Stop by if you get the chance. Thanks for this fine dessert tonight!
Cherrie
Reclaiming the Plunder of the Body Image Bandit
http://www.cherriemac.wordpress.com
Hi Cherrie. I’m so glad you found the site. I had a quick look at your work and it seems we’re definitely on a similar mission to empower women. Keep up the fight!
Joy – I never thought of it this way, but that makes so much sense. I decided not to diet this year – trying to lose baby weight has been frustrating and mostly an exercise in futility- especially since we’re buying a house an moving in the next two months. I didn’t want to waste my energies on calorie-counting and making myself feel bad for eating the foods I love. So I’m trying to be reasonable yet happy. But I never thought of dieting as a political/power tool. Thanks for the thoughtful point of view, and great writing.
Now I need to read Naomie Wolf’s book!
Hi Clara! Thanks for reading and I’m happy to hear you enjoyed the new perspective. Seems the media is all about losing baby weight in x amount of time these days – which puts even more pressure and unrealistic expectations on women, as you know. You might also like this article (http://www.about-face.org/raising-the-bar-on-bouncing-back-after-baby/) at about-face, another blog to which I contribute.
the word diet contains the word die. it is the most boring thing in the world. and the most depressing. when people like timothy ferriss speak of eliminating virtually everything from your diet for fat loss except yucky lentils, even more yucky rubbery egg whites and blech…spinach i want to spank him on his ass! what the hell is this??? this cannot be called living. it is a death in life. why not eat all the good things you want and have your eyes sparkle with abundant health rather then go the bodybuilders route of tasteless shitty egg whites and smelly seashore smegma like canned tuna. for 99% of our history we did not diet. we ate natural local produce no matter what the fucking calories, protein, carbs or fats in it. it is only in the last 1% of crazy screwed up overobsessive time lapse that we have started counting the number of grams of selenium in a pint of beer or the micrograms of cholesterol in a strip of bacon. what these bastard nutritionists don’t realize is what a waste of time this analysis paralysis is. it sucks the bloody juices out of life and one cannot enjoy it anymore. why go into the technical details. can’t we just pop a cherry in our mouth or take a swig from a glass of sugarcane juice? do we have to go into the complexities. no.no.no. just break the bone and suck the marrow out of life. two salutes to naomi wolf for this message of dieting as being the most potent political sedative. don’t diet, act now instead…even if you have to pay the price of ostracism or nonconformity. obedience is only for dogs. not for human beings!
I love this – the word diet contains the word “die.” So many people could benefit from making this their mantra. Are you interested in making a guest post? I’d like to “radicalise” this blog a bit more – get back to the meat and potatoes of ‘riot don’t diet’. If you’re interested in, perhaps expanding on this comment as a post, let me know (joy@followyrbliss.com). Cheers!